Photo by Adrian Hernandez on Unsplash
Debate focus
Religion
No description provided.
Activity
30-day signal flow
New debates, contributions, and reactions tied to this topic.
Activity score
40/100
11 total signals
Positions
6
Contributions
2
Reactions
3
Positions active
6
Contributions
2
Last 30d snapshot
Positions
Arguments on the table
Photo by Mohammad Mardani on Unsplash
Photo by alivia lusko on Unsplash
Photo by Konstantinos Ntinos on Unsplash
Photo by Pablo Rebolledo on Unsplash
Community feed
Recent contributions
jmarshallwalker42
1d agoOn: Religious groups are tax havens for the rich.
True, but that’s the whole point of religious exemptions - we inherently tax them differently. It can be argued that some instances, where “the rich” use these religious exemptions as a tax shelter, do exist - however this does not represent the majority of religious-based organizations. I would argue the majority of religious groups and organizations are performing a net-positive service and the tax exemptions are fair and justified. That being said, when we identify specific cases of fraud and abuse, these should be addressed and resolved - megachurch pastors with personal helicopters, for instance lol.
Intent summary: Argue that while religious tax exemptions can be abused by some wealthy individuals, most religious organizations provide public benefit and abuses should be handled case-by-case.
turkules
3d agoOn: Religious groups are tax havens for the rich.
Religion can allow a group or sect to collect funds as donations without taxation on the money, while also providing tax write-offs to donors, which can result in the same money being untaxed in multiple ways.
Intent summary: Argues that religious donation and tax-deduction structures can enable money to avoid taxation through multiple mechanisms.
Positions
Argument map
Religious groups are tax havens for the rich.
Religious belief is compatible with scientific reasoning.
Organized religion concentrates power in unhealthy ways.
Community feed
Live contributions
jmarshallwalker42
1d agoOn: Religious groups are tax havens for the rich.
True, but that’s the whole point of religious exemptions - we inherently tax them differently. It can be argued that some instances, where “the rich” use these religious exemptions as a tax shelter, do exist - however this does not represent the majority of religious-based organizations. I would argue the majority of religious groups and organizations are performing a net-positive service and the tax exemptions are fair and justified. That being said, when we identify specific cases of fraud and abuse, these should be addressed and resolved - megachurch pastors with personal helicopters, for instance lol.
Intent summary: Argue that while religious tax exemptions can be abused by some wealthy individuals, most religious organizations provide public benefit and abuses should be handled case-by-case.
turkules
3d agoOn: Religious groups are tax havens for the rich.
Religion can allow a group or sect to collect funds as donations without taxation on the money, while also providing tax write-offs to donors, which can result in the same money being untaxed in multiple ways.
Intent summary: Argues that religious donation and tax-deduction structures can enable money to avoid taxation through multiple mechanisms.